Who do you consult for job/career coaching advice?

I’m often asked to sit in on panel dicussions at conferences with professional recruiters, executive coaches, and human resource professionals to answer a variety of questions about the job market, résumés, cover letters, interviews, job and career strategies, and so on. But a recent experience revealed that not all career professionals are created equal.

This panel consisted of a seasoned HR professional, two professional recruiters, an executive coach, a “certified life coach,” and myself.  The session was moderated and questions for the panel were submitted prior to the actual meeting. Each person on the panel responded to the same question read by the moderator. About halfway through the audience Q&A session, an individual stood up and asked, “How many of you have direct responsibility for hiring people?”

The HR person and I raised our hands.

Her next question was, “How many of you have directly hired other people? I don’t mean you were involved in the hiring proces–I mean actually offered a job to someone?”

The HR person’s hand went up and so did mine.

Her last question was, “Which of you have actually managed the people you hired?”

This time, only my hand went up.

There was an audible mumbling in the audience after that, and some of panelists now seemed abit uncomfortable in front of the group. While everyone offered helpful and unique perspectives on career strategies and job searches, it became clear to the audience (about 120 people) that some advice and suggestions had more value than others. After the panel discussion session concluded, I was approached by about a dozen members of the audience who had more questions (the HR representative had a gathering as well as did one recruiter; the other recruiter, the life coach, and executive coach left the room when no one showed an interest in followup with them).

I didn’t know much about life/career/executive coaches so I did a little digging. According to one coaching website: “Many coaches evolved from the consulting, training or therapy industries, but a coach is different from a therapist, consultant, trainer or mentor.” There’s a type of “certified” coaching program for just about any kind of field or topic.

From my research, most of the certifications require online webinars and reading material and so many hours of experience coaching others in a variety of disciplines as shown in the table below:

Types of coaching

Types of coaching

Some certifications offer “Certified Professional Coach” and “Certified Master Coach” accreditation (depending on how many hours of experience you earn).  The point is: none of these types of coaches is directly involved with hiring others. They appear to help others improve various individual soft skillsets using a predefined menu of approaches; however, they don’t seem to respond to questions and concerns people have about making the connection with the people who do the actual hiring and managing. No doubt, coaching in confidence, motivation, peak performance, interpersonal skills, and so on can help people prepare those facets for career or job change, but the missing knowledge is on the other side of the equation with knowing how to respond to the needs and requirements of the people making the hiring decisions.

Just last week, I came across a message on LinkedIn from someone who’s a member of a LinkedIn special interest group to which I belong. She joyously proclaimed her recent move to the area and that she’s a “Certified Dream Coach.”

Welcome to my nightmare!


Tagged ,

One thought on “Who do you consult for job/career coaching advice?

  1. […] my May 2013 post on “Coaching” I related a story about participating in a panel discussion at a national conference with an HR […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: